I have read some blog and Facebook posts/comments recently by parents who dislike Scholastic, specifically Scholastic book fairs in schools and the quality of the books (or the lack of quality of the books). These comments got me thinking about why I like Scholastic and do not mind the book fairs, catalogs, and book quality.
Mind you, if there is one thing I will always purchase for my kids, it is books. Toys are not necessary and clothing is optional, but one can never have too many books.
Sure, there are some books out there that I don't like. I was never big into the Strawberry Shortcake books because 1. they are loooooong and 2. Strawberry Shortcake and her fruity friends always say things like, "This is berry cool!" When N was big into these books I did buy them and I did check them out from our local library, but I always read them as "This is very cool." The point was that she liked them, and I wanted (and want) her to like books and enjoy the pleasure of reading.
I recognize that the Scooby-Doo books and the Marvel Superhero books and the Barbie books are not great literature, but I think kids should be allowed to have their choice in reading. They will be far more willing to read things I suggest to them (better quality literature) if they know they are able to pick some of their favorites.
When I was a preteen/teen one of the books I read over and over and over was Jimmy Reardon by William Reichert. Not high quality literature, to be sure, but it got me reading, and I read it every time I sat at the kitchen table to have a snack.
Unless my kids want to read pornography before they are legally of age to purchase it, I do not ever see myself censoring their reading. I might postpone their reading, say if N wanted to read Forever by Judy Blume when she is 10. She can read it when she is the same age as the protagonist. (But I reserve the right to change my mind about this at any time.)
I don't mind the kids visiting the Scholastic book fair while at school and making a wish list. I have a much bigger problem with the kids being allowed to purchase chips and cookies in the lunch line. A book, even a crappy book, is far better for a kid than junk food.
Now, I never just give N money to purchase her own stuff from the book fair because she might be tempted to buy erasers or other little trinkets that are also sold. She makes her wish list of books, I go the book fair, I decide which of her choices I want to buy her that costs $5 or less, and she gets one book.
What does stick in my craw a bit are the Tag systems and other electronic "readers" that are advertised as being a great way to get kids to read. My kids like to read mostly because we have books all over our house, we have read to our kids at least once a day since they were six months old, I have taken them to the library on a regular basis their entire lives, and they see me and D reading almost constantly---magazines, newspaper, books. It is my belief that most kids will enjoy reading and read well if similar things are done in their homes from the time they are wee babies. Unless one of the kids has specific reading problems and I am encouraged by a reading professional to get them one of these systems, I will not purchase one. (But I also refuse to allows televisions in bedrooms, including mine and D's, so I am kinda in a small circle of Luddites.)
I'm going out on a limb here but do some parents buy these things for their kids just so they don't have to read to 'em?
If there is one book series that I have heard people rave about but that I don't get the hype, it is the Skippyjon Jones books. They are cute--yes--but I find them very confusing. And if I get confused, it makes me wonder if my kids aren't a little confused. Plus, I'm not big on the use of just adding "o" to the end of an English word to make it sound Spanish. I'd be curious to know how these books are received among Latinos.
Two titles I found in the Scholastic brochures that the kids and I have read and enjoyed are Pete the Cat: I Love My White Shoes and Pete the Cat: Rockin in My School Shoes, both by Eric Litwin and illustrated by James Dean. Perhaps the best thing about the books is that if one visits this site, one can download audio recordings. If you were driving around my city sometimes, you might see us rockin' out to these in the minivan. Pete is one funky cat.
Mind you, if there is one thing I will always purchase for my kids, it is books. Toys are not necessary and clothing is optional, but one can never have too many books.
Sure, there are some books out there that I don't like. I was never big into the Strawberry Shortcake books because 1. they are loooooong and 2. Strawberry Shortcake and her fruity friends always say things like, "This is berry cool!" When N was big into these books I did buy them and I did check them out from our local library, but I always read them as "This is very cool." The point was that she liked them, and I wanted (and want) her to like books and enjoy the pleasure of reading.
I recognize that the Scooby-Doo books and the Marvel Superhero books and the Barbie books are not great literature, but I think kids should be allowed to have their choice in reading. They will be far more willing to read things I suggest to them (better quality literature) if they know they are able to pick some of their favorites.
When I was a preteen/teen one of the books I read over and over and over was Jimmy Reardon by William Reichert. Not high quality literature, to be sure, but it got me reading, and I read it every time I sat at the kitchen table to have a snack.
Unless my kids want to read pornography before they are legally of age to purchase it, I do not ever see myself censoring their reading. I might postpone their reading, say if N wanted to read Forever by Judy Blume when she is 10. She can read it when she is the same age as the protagonist. (But I reserve the right to change my mind about this at any time.)
I don't mind the kids visiting the Scholastic book fair while at school and making a wish list. I have a much bigger problem with the kids being allowed to purchase chips and cookies in the lunch line. A book, even a crappy book, is far better for a kid than junk food.
Now, I never just give N money to purchase her own stuff from the book fair because she might be tempted to buy erasers or other little trinkets that are also sold. She makes her wish list of books, I go the book fair, I decide which of her choices I want to buy her that costs $5 or less, and she gets one book.
What does stick in my craw a bit are the Tag systems and other electronic "readers" that are advertised as being a great way to get kids to read. My kids like to read mostly because we have books all over our house, we have read to our kids at least once a day since they were six months old, I have taken them to the library on a regular basis their entire lives, and they see me and D reading almost constantly---magazines, newspaper, books. It is my belief that most kids will enjoy reading and read well if similar things are done in their homes from the time they are wee babies. Unless one of the kids has specific reading problems and I am encouraged by a reading professional to get them one of these systems, I will not purchase one. (But I also refuse to allows televisions in bedrooms, including mine and D's, so I am kinda in a small circle of Luddites.)
I'm going out on a limb here but do some parents buy these things for their kids just so they don't have to read to 'em?
If there is one book series that I have heard people rave about but that I don't get the hype, it is the Skippyjon Jones books. They are cute--yes--but I find them very confusing. And if I get confused, it makes me wonder if my kids aren't a little confused. Plus, I'm not big on the use of just adding "o" to the end of an English word to make it sound Spanish. I'd be curious to know how these books are received among Latinos.
Two titles I found in the Scholastic brochures that the kids and I have read and enjoyed are Pete the Cat: I Love My White Shoes and Pete the Cat: Rockin in My School Shoes, both by Eric Litwin and illustrated by James Dean. Perhaps the best thing about the books is that if one visits this site, one can download audio recordings. If you were driving around my city sometimes, you might see us rockin' out to these in the minivan. Pete is one funky cat.

















